Software engineering using rationale sciencedirect. A design rationale representation for modelbased designs in software engineering. Capture and maintain the rationale for all selections among alternatives and decisions for the design, architecture characteristics. The concept of design rationale, the why of designing, has emerged as a key to making design processes more intelligible and easier to deal with. Papers 4 in practice uml software architecture and design description, ieee software, 2006 the impact of uml documentation on software maintenance an experimental evaluation, ieee transactions on software engineering, vol. Design rational toolbox background aerospace engineering design relies heavily on the use of past experience. Part 1 fundamentals rationale representation, capture and use. The authors provide an introduction to design rationale and why it is important in software engineering.
The rationale would provide insight into why the system is the way it is by giving the reasons behind the design decisions, could help to indicate where changes might be needed during maintenance if design goals change, and help the maintainer avoid repeating earlier mistakes by explicitly documenting alternatives that were tried earlier that. Pdf a design rationale representation for modelbased. Engineering design is a blend of technology and appealing design. The reader will note that the design rationale created in this example is extremely weak, indeed it has no formal existence at all.
The participants represented the spectrum of software design, which was reflected in the discussions. Design rationale in exemplary business process modeling. Citeseerx design rationale for software engineering. It discusses how to take an idea and a model developed by a data scientist e. More has been written about software design rationale than about any other topic in research on software engineering rationale.
Aug 25, 2014 lecture 1 20090608 introduction to course, general history and definitions cs411 software architecture design dr. Software engineers produce lengthy design documents using computeraided software engineering tools. We provide an introduction to what design rationale is and why it is important in software engineering. A design rationale representation for modelbased designs. Lecture 1 20090608 introduction to course, general history and definitions cs411 software architecture design dr. In interior design, a design rationale explains the reasons behind decisions made when designing a space. Apr 29, 2017 a description of the set of architectural additions, subtractions and modifications to the software architecture, the rationale, and the design rules, design constraints and additional requirements that partially realize one or more requirements on a given architecture software architecture as a set of architectural design decisions paper. Understanding the barriers rationale as a byproduct hypermedia support for argumentationbased rationale. Technical report a survey of architecture design rationale. System design in software development the andela way medium. Design rationale as it applies to software architecture has become an established area of software engineering research. Since then, the software engineering community has experimented with several dr approaches such as issue based information systems ibis 11, questions, options, and. Three studies of design rationale as explanation effective design rationale.
How to write a design rationale jennifer cederstam. The chapters in this volume show how design rationale can be incorporated into the heart of the software development process into requirements engineering, software architecture, and code design. System design in software development the andela way. Rewrite the design problem introduced in the beginning of your design rationale, sum up your design solution, and stress its importance by proving to your reader that your design solution is the design solution. Software engineering using design rationale seurat 4 1. Sep 24, 2018 system design in software development. Rationale management in software engineering springerlink. We survey a number of the major systems developed for the support of design rationale, comparing their features and discussing their differences. This report summarizes the workshop with respect to the discipline of software engineering. Burge is an assistant professor at miami university computer science and systems analysis department. It is known that engineering designers frequently need to revisit previous design solutions and understand the rationale for their generation.
The rationalization, justification, and motivation of design decisions is a challenge in various engineering disciplines, including mechanical, electrical, software, and systems engineering, whose importance in modern environments gains slowlygrowing. Early work emphasizing the importance of design rationale in software design can be found in 9, 10. Software engineering using design rationale semantic scholar. Idef6 or integrated definition for design rationale capture is a method to facilitate the acquisition, representation, and manipulation of the design rationale used in the development of enterprise systems. They look at advantages and disadvantages of the various. Design rationale newcastle engineering design centre.
Rationale management in software engineering handbook of. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. When the designer chooses a design method, he indirectly determines the formal models that will be used to describe the artifact. Moreover, they facilitate the understanding and reevaluation of decisions, which is an important prerequisite for managing change during software development. Much work has gone into identifying the value of design rationale for software developers, maintainers and users. We look at the recent history of argumentation methods. While the spoon is a very basic example, the complex artifacts that humans make today invariably involve engineering design. Thirty years ago, i first entered the dark realm of software engineering, through a prior interest in documentation. It is these aspects of ebpm that we focus on in this contribution. The course includes a survey of current programming languages, advanced topics in a specific language, design patterns, code reorganization techniques, specification languages, verification and tools for managing.
Design rationale, in its simplest, is the explicit listing of decisions made during a design process and the reasons why those decisions were made. Design rationale management research the knowledge. This method, that wants to define the motives that drive the decisionmaking process, is still in development. A realistic empirical evaluation of the costs and benefits of. Using rationale to document designs software engineering design lecture 10 good design documentation documentation has an important role in sw eng there are many standards and methods for writing documents which typically specify their structure however, within a given document structure, it is still easy to write bad to useless documentation.
In those days, documentation pretty much meant functional specifications. Design rationale refers broadly to issues in the methods, documentation, and communication of design thinking. The course takes a software engineering perspective on building software systems with a significant machine learning or ai component. Design rationale in exemplary business process modeling 187 concepts, it is ideally suited to form the basis for design rationale extraction, especially in the context of customized software development. The course includes a survey of current programming languages, advanced topics in a specific language, design patterns, code reorganization techniques, specification languages, verification and tools for managing multipleprogrammer software projects. Ibm engineering systems design rhapsody overview ibm. This paper presents the kuaba ontology, a vocabulary for design rationale described in an ontology definition language that allows attributing semantics to recorded content, and defining rules that enable performing computable operations and. This should be the best part of your design rationale. The decisions a designer faces when designing a space includes. Ieee defines software design as both a process of defining, the architecture, components, interfaces, and other characteristics of a system or component and the result of that process. To successfully describe design rationale we must first address and attempt to. More than most generalpurpose programming languages, go was designed to address a set of software engineering issues that we had been exposed to in the construction of large server software. They look at advantages and disadvantages of the various approaches to design. Motivation for a number of years, members of the artificial intelligence ai in design community have studied design rationale dr, the reasons behind decisions made while designing.
May, 2010 papers 4 in practice uml software architecture and design description, ieee software, 2006 the impact of uml documentation on software maintenance an experimental evaluation, ieee transactions on software engineering, vol. The whole software design process has to be formally managed long before the first line of code is written. We survey a number of the major systems developed for the support of design rationale, comparing their features and discussing their. Design rationale for modelbased designs in software engineering. The worli sea link in mumbai, the fastest car in the world, the supersonic jets, smart phones, the burj khalifa and the latest innovation in diagnostic medicine all are examples of engineering design at work. A decision based design structure, which spans the areas of engineering design, design rationale and decision analysis. Rationale is the reason, justification, underlying motivation, or. Software architecture is the high level structure of a software system, the discipline of creating such a high level structure, and the documentation of this structure. He created the first hypertext systems for support of design rationale in the 1970s and 1980s and was the first to integrate support for rationale capture and delivery into 3d computeraided design systems.
Kunz and horst rittel, design rationale seeks to provide argumentationbased structure to the political, collaborative process of addressing wicked problems. Software design is a phase in software engineering, in which a blueprint is developed to serve as a base for constructing the software system. Engineering design is a very important aspect in all manmade artifacts products. Offhand, that might make go sound rather dull and industrial, but in fact the focus on clarity, simplicity. Rationales communicate the reasoning behind various requirements or development approaches to development teams. For a number of years, members of the artificial intelligence ai in design community have studied design rationale dr, the reasons behind decisions made while designing. Rationale management in software engineering book, 2006. Creativity and rationale in software design acm sigsoft. Software engineering using design rationale seurat 5 design maintenance using rationale to locate sources of design problems, to indicate where changes need to be made in order to modify the design, and to ensure that rejected options are not inadvertently reimplemented. Many benefits potentially stem from a structured representation and use of design rationales, i. Mar 12, 2020 rationale management in software engineering. Allen dutoit, ray mccall, ivan mistrik and barbara paech have done an excellent job of this in rationale management in software engineering.
Software engineering using design rationale by janet e. While there are several approaches for dealing with rationale knowledge, the systematic integration of rationale into software engineering processes and tools has yet to happen. May 30, 2015 created using powtoon free sign up at create animated videos and animated presentations for free. Rewrite the design problem introduced in the beginning of your design rationale, sum up your design solution, and stress its importance by proving to your reader that your design solution is the design solution to the design problem. Rationale, often referred to as design rationale, has been studied for many years for a variety of applications including engineering design, human computer interaction moran and carroll, 1995, and software development dutoit et al. Her major research interests are in software engineering and artificial intelligence. Josephson 2000 function in device representation, engineering with computers, special issue on computer aided engineering, vol. The software engineer then converts the design documents into design specification documents, which are used to design code. Created using powtoon free sign up at create animated videos and animated presentations for free.
Good design documentation using rationale to document. They survey a number of the major systems developed for the support of design rationale, comparing their features and discussing their differences. Early work emphasizing the importance of design rationale in software design can be found in. Documenting software architecture facilitates communication between stakeholders, captures early decisions about the highlevel design, and allows reuse of design components between projects.
The newcastle engineering design centre is a research centre for collaborative. Explicitlyrepresented rationales help us understand the design better so that we can produce a better design, maintain the resulting artifact better, and exploit the cumulated. Burge specializes in software engineering, design rationale. Citeseerx software engineering using design rationale. Standard design documentation consists of a description of the final design itself. Engineering design services providers use many cad cae tools to achieve their objective. Janet burge, associate professor of computer science, is teaching a service learning course, comp 342 software engineering, this fall. Capturing design rationale in concurrent engineering teams, computer, january, pp. Keep in mind that this is the part the readers remember best. An nsf sponsored workshop on creativity and rationale in software design was held at university park, pa in june, 2008. The ibm engineering systems design rhapsody rational rhapsody family of products offers a proven solution for modeling and design activities that allows you to manage the complexity many organizations face with product and systems development. Representing design rationale using an ontology definition language and the artifacts formal model, enables a type of software reuse at the highest abstraction.
Teams facing the challenge of designing, developing and engineering sophisticated products that cost less, in shorter periods of time and with fewer resources, must not only engineer new technologies but also integrate new solutions that drive faster time to market at lower cost from trusted vendors. The idea that stakeholders in a system its implementers, its endusers, its maintainers, and so forth might want something other than an alphabetic list. It provides a collaborative design, development and test environment for systems engineers and. A design rationale is an explicit documentation of the reasons behind decisions made when designing a system or artifact. Early work emphasizing the importance of design rationale in software design can be found in parnas and clements, 1985, potts and burns, 1988. A design rationale representation for modelbased designs in. Fundamentals rationale representation, capture and use \ r. The surveys resulted in several ways to classify design rationale tools.
Sep 23, 2014 janet burge, associate professor of computer science, is teaching a service learning course, comp 342 software engineering, this fall. Cs411 software architecture design lecture 01 youtube. Oct 21, 2019 this should be the best part of your design rationale. A survey of architecture design rationale sciencedirect. A design rationale is the explicit listing of decisions made during a design process, and the reasons why those decisions were made. Kunz and horst rittel, design rationale seeks to provide argumentation. A design rationale is an explicit documentation of the reasons behind decisions made when. Bedir tekinerdogan 20082009 summer this course teaches the basic concepts.
Systems to support the capture and use of design rationale are. Design rationale approaches in software engineering. A realistic empirical evaluation of the costs and benefits of uml in. They look at the recent history of argumentation methods. Three studies of design rationale as explanation \ s. Dr is invaluable as an aid for revising, maintaining, documenting, evaluating, and learning the design.
1337 519 346 467 574 434 945 544 695 64 732 547 40 819 1117 1416 132 871 971 978 196 127 20 1065 1432 280 1269 1009 736 1471 1338 26 229 1443 896 586 744 665 1001 58 484 756 1482 639 464 1385 1413 1095 1340 1026